• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Papa D Pizza – Authentic New York Style Pizza & Italian Dining in Orlando

Papa D Pizza in Orlando offers an inviting, family-style Italian dining experience known for its authentic New York-style pizzas and diverse menu, including pasta, wings, subs, and fresh salads. The cozy, clean setting paired with attentive, friendly service creates a welcoming atmosphere. Highlights include their flavorful pizzas—crispy yet tender—fluffy garlic knots, and hearty pasta dishes that locals rave about. Despite its modest strip mall location, the quality and warmth of the food and service stand out. Papa D Pizza truly captures the essence of classic Italian-American comfort food, making it a beloved spot for both casual lunches and relaxed dinners.

Papa D Pizza at a glance

  • Address 5106 Dr Phillips Blvd, Orlando, FL 32819, United States
  • Phone (407) 299-0033
  • Restaurant type Pizza restaurant , Italian restaurant , Restaurant .
  • Popular for Popular for lunch , Popular for dinner , Good for solo dining .

Photos & Gallery

Papa D Pizza: Reviews & Ratings

Nohemi Ramos
5

Came in for a late lunch early dinner. The place is very quaint and clean. The service is outstanding. Our server was really nice and attentive even though she was busy. The NY style pizza was really good, just a bit undercooked in the middle, but the flavor was there. Pasta looked delicious, salad was fresh and crispy and their garlic knots were fluffy and fresh.

Jimmy Lane
5

The extra large New York special was awesome as always, miss the chicken parm topping though! Best pizza in Orlando and very friendly service

Christian Levanti
5

The workers were very friendly and the place overall felt like a family environment. Mateo was a great server and the food and variety was incredible. From greats wings, pizza, pasta, subs you really get that all around Italian dining experience. Overall a great restaurant and would recommend.

Sherrie Hrachovina
5

You seat yourself table service in this small restaurant. The server will greet and come to your table very quickly. Service was very friendly. Food was delicious. The building is dated, but it is a strip mall, not their fault. It was clean. We had the garlic cheese bread, chicken Parmesan lunch special and a 16”pizza. Way more than enough for three people, we left with to go boxes, but we wanted to try a variety.

Jon Brown
5

We were pleasantly greeted when we arrived. The waitress was super patient and very professional with taking our order and very quick with drink refills. The food was very good. We ordered a single slice with extra cheese and an order of fettuccine with chicken and broccoli, salad and garlic knots. We can't wait to return!

David Slaton
5

The new owners are doing such a fantastic job of continuing the Papa D’s legacy. So much heart and excellence in this place. The pizza was delicious, very fresh and the ingredients were high quality. They also had gluten free dough my wife needed and enjoyed. My 7 year old got the Spaghetti and Meatballs and ate it all, she loved it. We had the best time, love this place!

Raphaela Cavalcanti
5

I ordered the Alfredo gnocchi. The gnocchi was perfect and the Alfredo sauce.. was AMAZING!!!! Best I ever had! Makes you want to drink the sauce and kiss the chef! I want to buy a gallon of it!

Location

  • Papa D Pizza
    Papa D Pizza
    5106 Dr Phillips Blvd, Orlando, FL 32819, United States Hotline: (407) 299-0033

Nestled on Dr Phillips Boulevard in Orlando, Papa D Pizza serves up a warm, inviting slice of New York-style Italian dining. This cozy, clean spot charms diners not only with its authentic flavors but also with genuinely attentive and friendly service that makes every visit feel like coming home.

What stands out most at Papa D Pizza is their dedication to classic comfort food done right. Their NY-style pizza offers a robust, flavorful bite, with a perfectly balanced crust—though a few reviewers note it can be slightly undercooked in the center, the rich, savory toppings more than make up for it. The extra-large New York special is a crowd-pleaser, consistently praised for its generous toppings and satisfying taste. Fans of Italian-American cuisine will also appreciate the diverse menu, featuring everything from tender chicken Parmesan to hearty pasta dishes like fettuccine with chicken and broccoli.

The garlic knots at Papa D Pizza deserve a special mention. Fluffy, fresh, and coated with just the right hint of garlic and butter, they offer a perfect start or accompaniment to any meal. Salads here are crisp and refreshing, providing a pleasant balance to the richer, more indulgent offerings. The garlic cheese bread and wings round out the menu, emphasizing the restaurant’s commitment to delivering a well-rounded Italian dining experience.

What truly elevates Papa D Pizza is the genuine care from the staff. Servers like Mateo receive praise for their upbeat, professional attentiveness, ensuring that each guest’s needs are met promptly, even during busy times. The atmosphere is described as familial and welcoming, solidifying Papa D Pizza not just as a place to eat, but a community hub where quality and warmth come together.

Though housed in a simple strip mall, the unpretentious setting allows the food and hospitality to take center stage. Whether you’re grabbing a late lunch, sharing a family dinner, or indulging in an oversized slice paired with garlic knots, Papa D Pizza promises an authentic Italian-American experience worth returning to.

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Has wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Has wheelchair-accessible entrance
    • Has wheelchair-accessible seating
    • Has wheelchair-accessible toilet
  • Service options
    • Has outdoor seating
    • Offers kerbside pickup
    • Has no-contact delivery
    • Offers delivery
    • Offers takeaway
    • Serves dine-in
  • Payments
    • Accepts credit cards
    • Accepts debit cards
    • Accepts NFC mobile payments
    • Credit cards